[from the Irish Times ; it's behind a paywall, so here is the full article]
The impressive ages of people who live in these areas may be due more to poor record keeping than healthy lifestyle habits
Blue zones are places where people reportedly
live in good health to over 100 years of age. These locations seem to
hold the secrets of exceptional longevity wrapped up in the warm glow of
red wine with family.
Blue zones are a
lovely idea, but they likely don’t exist. In fact, the extreme age of
people who live in these areas may be more due to poor record keeping
than healthy lifestyle habits.
Examples
of blue zones include Okinawa in Japan, Loma Linda in California,
Sardinia in Italy and Ikaria in Greece. These areas have been studied in
detail to understand why their people live such long and healthy lives
and, more importantly, what we can do to emulate their longevity
successes.
The common factors include
daily activity, drinking red wine, prioritising family, eating
vegetables, having faith in something, taking time off, and celebrating
life. These are (mostly) all very sensible things most people could
integrate into their lives. But while all the blue zones mentioned have
these factors in spades, it doesn’t take long to realise that endless
small towns around the world, particularly in the Mediterranean, share
these traits, yet lack exceptional longevity.
Why do these blue zones have populations
that are routinely dying at over 100 years of age if it’s not down to
the factors listed above?
It’s worth
looking more closely at these areas and the factors that unite them.
Some other factors common to blue zones include poor birth and death
registration, poverty, specifically old-age poverty, high crime rates,
worse health metrics, and remote regions of birth.
In some blue zones, rates of smoking are
often as high as 50 per cent, and rates of illiteracy reach as high as
80 per cent. This is not exactly what you would expect from an area
where people are supposed to have exceptionally long and healthy lives.
As
a centenarian or supercentenarian who has lived to over 110 years, you
would have been born when the record-keeping of births and deaths was
either not present or less robust. The number of supercentenarians plummeted
after the rollout of mandatory birth registration and census keeping in
the United States. This suggests that when formal record-keeping was
mandated, self-estimations of age, which were common practice at the
time, were no longer accepted.
But the
strange birth registration issues don’t end there. Supercentenarians
born in the US are 1.5 times more likely to be born on the first day of
the month. In Japan, that figure rises to 2.7 times. This, to put it
mildly, seems a little odd. When countries attempt to count their true
number of centenarians, they are frequently surprised to learn that many
of them are already dead. A 2010 Japanese investigation discovered that
almost a quarter of a million of their centenarian population was
already deceased. A similar investigation in the US found that 35 per
cent of all supercentenarians were already dead. Of all the
supercentenarians in the US and France, not one has an authentic birth
certificate. Record-keeping for those born in the early 1900s in areas
of the world that have struggled with poverty has been subpar.
In
reality, blue zones may be more of an artefact of poor record keeping
rather than lifestyle. But that doesn’t mean we should ignore the
lifestyle patterns identified in blue zones. They probably won’t be the
determining factor that gets you to 110 years of age; they are, however,
a great place to start if you want to add ten years to your life and
live to 90.
Rather than focusing on
blue zones, it is better to examine lifestyle factors in longer-term
studies and see how they impact lifespan. When people get the basics
right by age 50 – not smoking, maintaining a normal weight, being active
daily, maintaining modest alcohol intake, and maintaining a good diet –
they can extend their lives by over a decade. That is more than a 10
per cent life extension. This means that the average male who gets these
factors in check by age 50 will die on average at 87, and the average
female who gets them right will live on average to 93.
Getting
them right is unlikely to get you to 110, as the blue zones would
suggest, but you’re likely to live significantly longer than those who
don’t get them right. What is even more important is that getting these
healthy factors right can delay the onset of many serious medical
conditions, including heart disease, cancer and type 2 diabetes, by 10
years. An additional 10 years without a major illness means the life
years gained will be much higher quality. Adhering to these healthy
patterns does not guarantee longevity, but it seriously increases the
odds.
If following a “blue zone” diet or way of
life seems attractive to you, the data shows that it will likely extend
your life by over a decade – just don’t plan on it extending your life
to over 110 years of age. For that, you might need to work on your birth
certificate forgery skills.
Dr Paddy Barrett is a preventive cardiologist at the Blackrock clinic and author of Heart An Owner’s Guide
===
and my view: The point of Dr Barett is that the blue zones do not exist. This point is irrelevant! The real point should be to focus on the Power of 9 and how we can create more places where people follow the Power of 9.
Blue zones do exist, as I am writing at my latest book
Preventing Inflammation and Cardiovascular Diseases: How Food Polar Lipids Can Reduce Inflammation
and this short interview proves this point and it worth watching.