I have to confess that since my childhood, and thanks to my parents (my mum was a teacher and then a Principal in a Comprehensive school that was named after Miltos Kountouras and my dad was a chemist and economist combining Chemistry with Business and a fan of Beethoven and Theodorakis) I was exposed to unconventional educational literature from very young, like this and that.
Later on, we came across the work of Miltos Kountouras and the school I went to was renamed after Miltos. One of the best books that Miltos has written is this one, unfortunately available only in Greek "Κλείστε τα Σχολειά" where he describes the need for a new school based on mutual respect, more freedom and polyphony. That book was written from April to July 1923, 97 years ago but it is still so fresh and valid.
All this educational and pedagogical background reading came so useful when I was doing my M.Ed. in the University of Leeds, studying about learning outcomes, means/ways of active teaching and how active learning differs to teaching, how videotaping myself was one of the best ways of feedforwarding (I think the word "feedback" has a negative - backwards connotation) and most of all the value of problem based learning (PBL). I loved PBL and I chose it as an educational tool in my MEd thesis.
All these years, I still remember vividly this story from Leo's Book "Living, Loving & Learning"
This is a tale, an illustrative tale titled The Animal School — a story Leo loves “because it’s so wild, yet so true”:
(the wording is Leo's wording, as published in 1982)
"The animals got together in the forest one day and decided to start a school. There was a rabbit, a bird, a squirrel, a fish and an eel, and they formed a Board of Education.
The rabbit insisted that running be in the curriculum.
The bird insisted that flying be in the curriculum.
The fish insisted that swimming be in the curriculum, and the squirrel insisted that perpendicular tree climbing be in the curriculum.
They put all of these things together and wrote a Curriculum Guide.
Then they insisted that all of the animals take all of the subjects.
Although the rabbit was getting an A in running perpendicular tree climbing was a real problem for him; he kept falling over backwards. Pretty soon he got to be sort of brain damaged, and he couldn’t run any more. He found that instead of making an A in running, he was making a C and, of course, he always made an F in perpendicular tree climbing.
The bird was really beautiful at flying, but when it came to burrowing in the ground, he couldn’t do so well. He kept breaking his beak and wings. Pretty soon he was making a C in flying as well as an F in burrowing, and he had a hellava time with perpendicular tree climbing.
The moral of the story is that the animal who was valedictorian of the class was a mentally retarded eel who did everything in a halfway fashion. But the educators were all happy because everybody was taking all of the subjects, and it was called a broad-based education".
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Fast forward to 2020, today, with covid-19 having closed schools and Universities around the world, it is time to think, to re-think, to evaluate our teaching and assessing practices.
Since March 13th, I am watching every morning my boys (13 and 16) waiting for a boring email on Teams with more homework.
47 days since schools closed in Ireland, only yesterday my younger one had an online class.
The older one, Junior Cert year, had no online classes for.... 47 days now!
Why is it so hard to have a Teams online class at least once a week? To keep the class and team spirit up?
And the boring emails are still coming but this is not education, is it?
Let's think.
What are we teaching?
Why have we chosen these subjects?
How do we assess these modules?
Moving to online teaching and assessment, what do we need to modify?
Can we deliver lab-practicals online?
If not, how can we produce a blended-delivery of courses?
Exams where students have to recite word by word are not promoting meritocracy , for sure. We need people able to think, to analyse , to synthesise , not to memorise information that is only two clicks away. In the era with a plethora of e-resources and online educational tools, we may have to wonder: why are we still functioning like Leo's "The Animal School" ?
Why aren’t we thinking beyond conventional exams and predictive marking? By addressing these points, with one stone we could kill two birds: modernising Leaving Cert exams and creating online course that could attract distance-learning students from all over the world. Extraordinary times require out of the box approaches.
Ioannis Zabetakis
UL
No comments:
Post a Comment