![]() |
| A 1982 film of Pink Floyd’s The Wall featured artwork by cartoonist Gerald Scarfe. Photograph: Alamy Stock |
I have two boys,
the older one is Y3, Junior Cert year.
As I wrote last week on Sunday Times,since March 13th, they are waiting every morning for a (boring) email with homework.
No live classes.
No live interaction as a class with year tutors or teachers.
Only last week,they had one or two such classes.
Last Friday, for my older boy, I got this email from the School (the name of the school is irrelevant).
"Some parents have asked for further clarification on the structure of the Summer Exams/ Assessments. Understandably, there is demand for devices in the home, particularly, when you have more than one child of school going age, coupled with parents working from home. We have taken on board your concerns with this issue, and that is why we are not scheduling an exam timetable. This, it is hoped, will allow some flexibility in relation to when devices can be used by different members of the family. What we envisage for 3rd & 5th year exams, is that all teachers will issue all exams on Monday 18th May, through the usual platform of Microsoft Teams. Each assessment will be one hour long. The students will decide for themselves what exams they will complete first, they will time themselves, and will submit the exam once it's done. They will have until 4pm on Friday May 22nd to have all assessments completed and submitted"
So, in simple words, the school is going to base the 70% assessment of Junior Cert exams
on an assessment which is structured like that:
the lads will have access to ALL the exam questions from Monday 18th May and they have to submit their answers by 4pm on Friday 22nd.
The School expects (sic!) that the lads (15 and 16 year old boys!) to show discipline in their homes/rooms and time themselves (time limit is an hour) while they write their answers.
No point to comment on this.
Pedagogically, educationally, managerially and from what ever scope you want to examine it, it utterly poor practice. No further comments on this.
Yesterday, the Government announced that the Leaving Cert assessments are going to be based on predictive grades. Here is my view
![]() |
| estimation? How? Standardization? How? |
This morning, I read this Letter in the Irish Times
Charles makes some strong points in his letter.
Academics are interesting minds; we like thinking outside the box, so, let's think the opposite.
What about if we could having exams for Junior Cert and Leaving Cert students on line?
What would we need for that?
We need to make sure that every student has a laptop or a tablet and good wifi signal.
If some students have a weak wifi signal at home, they could simply go to their school with all their books.
Now, let's see what is needed for all students in Ireland to have a laptop or tablet.
In Leaving Cert, we have about 60.000 students and let's say another 60.000 at Junior Cert.
In total, we are talking about 120.000 students.
The manufacturing cost for a good tablet/laptop is about €200. Therefore, we would need
120.000 x €200 = €24M to provide all Junior and Leaving Cert students in Ireland a free tablet/laptop.
The Government could easily ask the big IT companies based in Ireland and taking profit of the low corporation taxation rates to donate 24M.
Simple and Easy? Yes!
Political cost? Negligible!
So, why nobody in the Government thought about that since 12th March when schools closed?
Lack of imagination?
Poor crisis management skills?
I rest my case._
Ioannis Zabetakis
P.S. We (and our children and our students) do not need no education.




No comments:
Post a Comment