source: Irish Times
Imagine a person who can only lose
weight, not by going on a diet, but by accidentally running out of
food. It is a grim fact that Ireland’s only really effective way of
responding to climate change has been to go into recession. We succeed
by failing.
Since
2005 the most significant reductions in greenhouse gas emissions were
caused by the implosion of the economy between 2008 to 2012. This
“success” will be repeated in 2020 because of the coronavirus crisis,
whose main benign effect is a likely reduction in Irish carbon emissions
of around 12 per cent this year.
If
the recession it causes is deep enough, we may even, as Samuel Beckett
has it, fail better. It is an Irish twist on the idea of collateral
damage: collateral benefit. Bomb the economy and we get some green
shoots of climate action.
We have a very clear example right next door of the viability of rapid change. If Scotland can do it, so can Ireland
As a
strategy, this surely has its limits. But of course, it is not a
strategy at all. It is accident, not action. The decent environmental
consequences, when we’ve had them, have been not merely unintended but
unwanted. They result, not from getting our act together, but from
things falling apart. Once we get up and running and again, we go back
to pumping out the gases.
What
does it say about leadership on climate change when disasters have been
much more effective in allowing us to meet our international
obligations than any official plans?
If
Ireland is to get anywhere close to fulfilling the stated aim of being a
leader on climate change, it must start with a radically transformed
sense of national purpose.
The
best way to grasp what this means is simply to look to the country that
is probably closest to Ireland in size, geography and culture:
Scotland. The Scottish government is less powerful than ours – it does
not enjoy full sovereignty. Yet its performance on climate change is
light years ahead of Ireland’s.
Scotland
deliberately made things hard for itself. The UK government set a
target of a 32 per cent reduction by 2020 on the level of greenhouse gas
emissions in 1990. In the Climate Change Act unanimously adopted by the
Scottish Parliament in 2009, the target is 42 per cent by 2020 and 80 per cent by 2050.
How has it fared?
Radical change
Scotland
will not reach its 42 per cent reduction target in 2020. It met it in
2015, five years early. It is now at 47 per cent. It went from getting
10 per cent of its electricity consumption from renewable sources 15
years ago to 60 per cent now. It is on track to get near its 100 per
cent target in the early 2020s.
And
Scotland’s neighbour to the west? More like its evil twin. Ireland set
less ambitious targets and failed abysmally to meet them.
Ireland’s
target was a 20 per cent reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2020,
relative to 2005 levels. Before the coronavirus crisis, the
Environmental Protection Agency’s emissions projections indicated that,
by 2020, a reduction of between five and six per cent will have been
achieved.
Scotland’s leaders deliberately chose a target high enough to excite their citizens
Without
radical and rapid change, cumulative Irish emissions of greenhouse gases
are also on course to exceed the 2030 target of 376 million tonnes of
carbon dioxide equivalent, by between 52 and 67 million tonnes.
In
Scotland, emissions from transport increased by 0.4 per cent from 1990
to 2017. Over the same period in Ireland, emissions from transport rose
by 133 per cent. Scotland already gets twice the proportion of its
electricity (60 per cent) from renewables as Ireland does (30 per cent).
Scotland
is on course to plant 10,000 new hectares of forestry every year. The
rate of afforestation in Ireland in 2017 actually fell to 5,000
hectares, with provisional figures for 2018 falling even further to
4,000 hectares. At these rates, Ireland will not attain the national
policy goal of covering 18 per cent of land with forest any time in the
21st century, let alone within the lifetime of any current climate
action plan.
At
one level, this shameful contrast is actually good news. It makes a
nonsense of the claims that radical reductions in Ireland’s emissions
are extremely hard to achieve or wildly impractical. We have a very
clear example right next door of the viability of rapid change. If
Scotland can do it, so can Ireland.
But
we have to start with the obvious question: why are the Scottish and
Irish records so starkly different? The answer has nothing to do with
resources and everything to do with leadership. One country has been
well led on climate change, the other – to put it very charitably – has
not.
Looking
at the Scottish experience, five things stand out in defining the way
this good leadership expressed itself. These are the things an incoming
Irish government should copy and paste.
1. Pride
First,
Scotland took pride in setting itself a big challenge. People are
motivated by thrilling new possibilities, not by grudging concessions.
While Ireland set the bar low and failed abjectly to clear it,
Scotland’s leaders deliberately chose a target high enough to excite
their citizens.
As
Andrew Kerr, executive director of the Edinburgh Centre for Carbon
Innovation, told the Citizens’ Assembly in Dublin in 2017: “Political
vision and leadership in putting forward a challenging target, and
corralling the resources and narrative around delivering that target,
was as important for setting the framework for tackling climate change
as robust evidence that it was achievable.”
The
dominant tone on climate change from Irish governments has been
negative – this is bad stuff we are being forced to do because we had to
sign all these international agreements.
Even
now, action on the single most important question facing humanity is
framed negatively. It is not climate change that “threatens rural
Ireland”, for example – it is the action needed to prevent it. The Scots
decided to tell themselves a different story: we can do this. Ireland’s
story has never got beyond: do we really have to do this?
Ironically,
one of the reasons for this may be that Scotland has been debating
national independence. The idea of a big collective project, a practical
expression of national willpower, fed into – and was in turn fed by – a
desire on the part of Scots to prove to themselves that they could
achieve big things together.
Ireland,
with a century of independence behind it, seems to have lost that
collective desire. If we are to get serious about climate change we will
have to find it again.
2. Monitoring
Second,
having set these ambitious targets, the Scots had rigorous independent
monitoring and analysis of how they were doing. Measuring how things
were progressing became, in Kerr’s words, “a normal part of
parliamentary debate and engagement, involving extensive consideration
each year”.
Scotland
was a pioneer in developing rigorous systems of monitoring and
evaluation, with annual reporting to parliament and a major assessment
of progress by a fully independent body every two years.
Ireland,
by contrast, did not even pass a Climate Change Act until 2015 – six
years after the Scottish Parliament did so. The EPA monitors emissions
and there is now a very capable Climate Change Advisory Council.
But
“advisory” is the key word. Irish governments are very good at ignoring
advice they don’t want to hear. There is no effective mechanism for
holding government departments or public bodies accountable for meeting
specific targets in specific time frames.
Scotland has had very strong civil society engagement on climate change
As the
Oireachtas climate change committee recommended last year, the “advisory
council” needs to be replaced by a powerful “action council”, which
will, among other things, produce five-year carbon budgets. It must have
its own statutory multi-annual funding to ensure its independence.
But
these changes need to be part of a much bigger transformation of the
official mindset. Behind those appalling increases in emissions from
transport, for example, is an inability to link the way we plan urban
development to climate change.
If
you make housing unaffordable in the big cities, you force people to
commute long distances. If you don’t invest sufficiently in public
transport, commuting is done in cars that emit greenhouse gases. Ireland
has ended up with one vehicle for every two people (including children)
and we now drive nearly 50 billion km a year.
3. No trade-off
Third,
the Scots refused to frame the whole question as a trade-off between
the environment and the economy. Perhaps because Scotland was already a
major oil producer, it was primed to think of the development of
renewable energy as a huge economic opportunity.
Scotland
sought successfully to attract investment into these new energy
sources. Doing the right thing could also be credibly presented as a
strategy for economic growth.
In
Ireland, by contrast, the issues are largely framed in terms of
reductions in activity – cutting the excessively large national beef
herd, for example. Good leadership should articulate the benefits of
replacing expensively imported oil and gas, creating new jobs and
developing new technologies.
4. Ownership
The
fourth thing the Scots have been good at is fostering a sense of
community ownership. This is not just a matter of encouraging and
supporting local communities in developing their own energy projects. It
is also about literal ownership.
The
Scottish government set a target for 500 megawatts of locally owned
energy generation facilities by 2020. It has already exceeded this and
reset the target to 1,000 megawatts. Profits from these projects return
to the communities who can then decide how best to invest the money.
Unsurprisingly, planning objections to wind farms are much rarer in
Scotland than in Ireland.
5. Engagement
Fifth,
Scotland has had very strong civil society engagement on climate
change. It has not been an issue only for environmental activists.
Churches, trade unions, scientists and business leaders pushed for the
more ambitious targets to be adopted and met.
Business groups like the Scottish Whisky Association
have pushed hard on the benefits of Scotland being seen globally as a
clean, green place. Builders switched to constructing timber-framed
houses, which are both more environmentally friendly and a good fit with
large-scale forestry planting.
Absence of leadership
We
don’t have to look very far, therefore, to see what good leadership
looks like. Generate a sense of national purpose. Set up rigorous
monitoring of, and accountability for, very specific targets. Embrace
the economic opportunities. Give communities ownership. Keep civil
society and businesses engaged.
But
none of this is going to happen in Ireland if adapting to climate
change is approached through the usual miasma of grudge and grievance.
Or if we fail to understand that the economy cannot be restarted after
the coronavirus crisis – it must be reimagined. Or if meeting our
international obligations is framed as a concession by the “mainstream”
to the Green Party rather than a collective challenge for government,
society and the economy.
The
absence of leadership emerged in the recent Sign of the Times 2020
study as the biggest factor in public disheartenment about Irish
responses to climate change. Part of the problem, though, seemed to be
that people were looking for saintly figures like David Attenborough to lead them. There won’t be any in the next Irish government.
But
leadership doesn’t need to be saintly. It needs to be challenging,
rigorous, accountable and decisive. If people can’t manage to meet those
standards, they shouldn’t be in government at all. If they can, this is
the time to show it.
No comments:
Post a Comment