Sunday, 19 July 2020

Incinerators lay pollution waste (upd)




Letter to the Editor; Sunday Times; 19.7.2020


Incinerators lay pollution waste 

With regard to your report “Meath incinerator seeks to double hazardous waste capacity” (News, July 5) the identity of the “hazardous waste” is not fully known.

Furthermore, the system in place for monitoring gas emissions and other by-products (heavy metals?) raises doubts as to whether it can properly monitor pollutants in real time, and make the data publicly available on a continuous basis. Cross-contamination of water and the food chain cannot be excluded, given the limited data. Without this information in place, how can the Environmental Protection Agency grant an operational permit? Furthermore, the “Trojan horse” process by which polluters can apply for incineration licences and return later to apply for significant increases in gross tonnages, and the right to burn new types of hazardous waste, effectively allows them to evade scrutiny.
CRH in Platin was originally granted a licence to incinerate 120,000 tons of waste. Their latest application would increase this to 600,000, with significant increases in the proportion of hazardous materials.
Claire Keating, Derek O’Dwyer, Ioannis Zabetakis, Limerick


= = = =
here is the full letter as sent to ST.


Letter to the Editor -   Sunday Times
                                                                                                                                 Limerick, 14th July 2020
Dear Sir,

With regard to the report of Colin Coyle “Meath incinerator seeks to double hazardous waste capacity” Sunday Times 5.7.2020, we would like to highlight the following points:
1.       The identity of “hazardous waste” is not fully known at the time of application for permit.
2.       The monitoring system of gas emissions and other by-products (heavy metals?) that is in place raises some doubts around its efficacy to properly monitor pollutants in real time and make these data publicly available on a continuous basis.
3.       Possible cross-contamination of water (inland or sea) and the food chain can not be excluded given the limited data known at the time of application. Without this information in place, how can EPA grant operational permit?
4.       Lastly, there is clear conflict in how incineration (and any other possibly polluting) processes are monitored across EU. In all member states, the authority with responsibility for granting the operational permit (license) is the same authority that monitors the legal operation of the facility.  In Ireland’s case, it’s the EPA. This effectively prevents the EPA from effectively applying “the polluter pays” principle which dictates that the polluter has to pay the full amount to compensate total environmental damage (in case, for example, of a possible leak of heavy metals).
5.       Furthermore, the “Trojan Horse” process by which polluters can apply for incineration licenses and return later to apply for significant increases in gross tonnages and rights to burn new types of hazardous waste allows polluters to evade scrutiny and mask legitimate public concerns on their longer-term intentions. For example, CRH in Platin were originally granted a license to incinerate 120,000 tonnes of waste. Their latest application would increase this to 600,000 tonnes per annum with significant increases in the proportion of hazardous materials.


Sincerely,

Claire Keating, Derek O’Dwyer
Limerick Against Pollution, Limerick
and Ioannis Zabetakis, Lecturer, Univ. of Limerick

P.S. Hong Kong incineration plans blasted by Prof Paul Connett - who advocates Zero Waste


No comments: