In nutritional value, we all know that the BEST milk is the human milk for two main reasons:
a. human milk contain natural anti-bodies that boost the baby's immune system and
b. the amino acid profile of human's milk is very similar to what we need as humans.
The other three milks, though, how do they compare?
When comparing solid, fat, protein and calcium contents along with calories, it is useful to have in mind the following table.
Composition of different kinds of
milk
| Species |
% solids
|
% Fat
|
% protein
|
calcium (mg)
|
calories (kcal)
|
| Human |
12.5
|
4.38
|
1.03
|
32
|
70
|
| Cow |
12.01
|
3.34
|
3.29
|
119
|
69
|
| Goat |
12.97
|
4.14
|
3.56
|
134
|
69
|
| Sheep |
19.30
|
7.0
|
5.98
|
193
|
108
|
| Source: The nutritional value of sheep milk by George F. W. Haenlein http://www.sheep101.info/dairy.html | |||||
But, when we want to compare the nutritional value of milks and yogurts, we need to assess their individual impact against a particular biochemical factor.
In our work, we assess the lipids of each food sample against the aggregation of platelets, using a machine called "platelet aggregometer" and we calculate the IC 50 values of all samples.
IC50 stands for Inhibitory Concentration 50 and the lower it is the more active is this fraction against inflammation and the development of CardioVascular Diseases (CVDs).
So, we studied the TL (total lipids) and TPL (total polar lipids) of 3 yogurt samples - made from cow's, goat's and sheep's milk.
We assessed TL and TPL for their
ability to inhibit the PAF-induced washed platelet aggregation (IC50).
The corresponding results for biological activity are expressed in
micrograms (μg) for the TL and TPL fractions of all yogurt samples and
are presented in Fig. 1.
- Fig. 1.
In vitro biological activities of total lipids (TL) and total polar lipids (TPL) of cow, ewe and goat yogurts towards washed rabbit platelet aggregation, expressed in micrograms of TL and TPL. Washed rabbit platelet concentration was approximately 500,000 platelets μL −1. The final concentration of PAF in the cuvette was 2.5 × 10−11 M. The experimental analyses were carried out in triplicate (n = 3).
According to Fig. 1,
both the TL and TPL fractions of all three yogurt samples have been
found to exert inhibitory activity, thus, it could be suggested that
these fractions contain lipids that act as PAF inhibitors.
The IC50 values for the TL and TPL goat yogurt samples (33.0 μg and 15.4 μg, respectively), were found to be significantly lower (p
< 0.05) compared to the values for ewe yogurt (43.1 μg and 27.2 μg,
respectively) and cow yogurt (45.4 μg and 40.8 μg, respectively) ( Fig. 1).
At this point, it should be emphasized that the lower the IC50
value, the stronger the anti-thrombotic potency of the lipid fraction,
since less amount of lipid is required to exert 50% inhibition of the
PAF-induced washed platelet aggregation.
We have also compared the sensory properties of these yogurts.
- Fig. 2.
Comparison of sensory profiles of cow, ewe and goat yogurt samples. The scores for a) taste b) aftertaste and c) texture attributes are given as spider-web plots.The sheep yogurt sample has been found to rate significantly higher for the taste attributes of “fatty”, “rich”, “delicious”, and “whey” and for the texture attribute “‘grainy”’.On the other hand, the goat yogurt sample has been found to rate significantly higher for the attribute of “sour” for taste, the attributes of “persistent”, “intense”, and “goaty” for the aftertaste and the attributes of “velvety”, “smooth” and “fluid” for the texture.The cow yogurt samples have been found to rate significantly higher only for the aftertaste attribute of “sweet”.
Up to now, all our data, suggest that sheep and goat yogurts and cheeses have strong cardioprotective properties and this is a fact that we can include in our every day choice of yogurts and cheeses.
We are now investigating the lipid profiles of these yogurts and how we can enrich them in “heart healthy fats” (these are what in food chemistry we call “polar lipids”) that are active against platelet aggregation and therefore the onset of CVDs.
On going work, funded by Enterprise Ireland, in the Department of Biological Sciences at the University of Limerick, is on yogurts and how lipolysis affects the cardioprotective properties of the final products.
Ioannis Zabetakis
Further reading
1. Evaluation of sensory and in vitro anti-thrombotic properties of traditional Greek yogurts derived from different types of milk
2. Evaluation of the in vitro anti-atherogenic activities of goat milk and goat dairy products
P.S. Siobhan is definitely not an ordinary sheep!
No comments:
Post a Comment